Skip to content

What is a vote threshold?

What a vote threshold measures, where the rule comes from, the majority of the minority and a real example.

What it is

A vote threshold is how much support the merger needs, counted in shares or votes.

Also called: Vote threshold basis

In plain words

Say 100 club members vote on selling the clubhouse. The rules might say more than half of all members must say yes.

Or they might say more than half of those who vote. That is easier to meet, because members who stay home don't count.

The vote threshold is that rule: how much support a deal needs, and what it is counted against.

What the threshold measures

A merger vote passes only with enough support. The vote threshold says how much, and what it's counted against.

Say Litware has 100 million shares outstanding. At the meeting on Woodgrove's $50.00 offer, 45 million shares vote for, 15 million against, and 40 million don't vote.

The same 45 million votes for under two rules: how many votes each rule needs, in millions, and whether the deal passes.
RuleNeedsResult
Majority of shares outstandingOver 50Fails
Majority of votes castOver 30Passes

Against all 100 million shares, the deal needs more than 50 million votes for. Against the 60 million votes cast, it needs more than 30 million.

The same votes can pass under one rule and fail under another.

Where the rule comes from

The law of the state where the company is incorporated sets the default. Its charter can ask for more.

For a Delaware company, Section 251(c) requires votes for the deal from a majority of the outstanding stock entitled to vote.Source 1

A charter can set a higher share, such as two-thirds. That's called a supermajority.

Some states let a charter ask for less: a majority of the votes cast, if enough shares are present at the meeting. A share that isn't voted then counts neither for nor against.

Majority of the minority

Some deals also need approval from the holders not tied to the buyer or the deal. It's called a majority of the minority.

It appears in deals where the buyer already controls the company. It also appears where insiders are on the buying side, as in a going-private transaction.

A deal's terms can count it against those holders' outstanding shares, or only their votes cast. For a Delaware company, Section 144 counts it as a majority of the votes cast by holders not tied to the deal.Source 2

Some going-private deals are by a controlling holder. In those, Section 144 offers protection when two approvals meet its conditions. One is a committee of disinterested directors. The other is a vote of those holders, fully informed and free of pressure.

With both, courts generally can't block the deal or award damages over certain claims of breach of duty. Other kinds of claims remain possible.

A real example

Juniper Networks agreed to sell itself to Hewlett Packard Enterprise. To approve the sale, it needed votes from a majority of its outstanding shares.

On the February 23, 2024 record date, it had 324,381,417 shares outstanding. So the deal needed 162,190,709 votes for.Source 3

At the meeting on April 2, 2024, 265,381,658 shares voted for, 258,541 against and 53,036 abstained.Source 4

Brokers couldn't vote their customers' shares on the merger without instructions. So shares at a broker with no instructions counted like votes against.Source 3

Votes for came to about 81.8% of the outstanding shares.

What it means for shareholders

Under the SEC's Schedule 14A, the proxy statement must state the vote required. It must also say how abstentions and broker non-votes count.Source 5

A broker non-vote happens when a broker votes a client's shares on routine items, but can't vote them on this one without instructions.

The threshold decides whether holders approve the deal, not who gets paid. In a cash merger that closes, shares voted against usually convert into the cash too. Holders who properly demand appraisal may get a value set by a court instead.

On Tracking Alpha

Tracking Alpha's deal list and deal pages aren't open to the public yet. Once they open, they'll work as described here.

Majority of shares outstanding
More than half of the outstanding shares entitled to vote, so a share that isn't voted counts against.
Majority of votes cast
More than half of the votes cast at the meeting.
Majority of the minority
A majority counted only among certain shares. Shares held by the buyer, its affiliates or others the agreement leaves out don't count.
Supermajority
A share higher than a majority.
Written consent
Holders with enough votes have approved in writing: see written consent.

Vote threshold basis, a line of its own, says whether the vote is measured against the shares outstanding or the votes cast.

Easily confused with

Shareholder vote
The vote itself. The threshold is how much support it needs to pass.
Minimum tender condition
The stake a tender offer needs, as its terms define it. Shares the buyer already owns may count. It plays the threshold's role there.

Questions

What percentage of the shares must vote for a merger?

It depends on the company's state and charter. For a Delaware company, the default is a majority of the outstanding shares entitled to vote. A charter or the deal can ask for more.

Do abstentions count as votes against a merger?

Where the deal needs a majority of the outstanding shares, they have the same effect, since they aren't votes for. Where it needs a majority of the votes cast, they usually don't count either way.

Do the buyer's own shares count in the vote?

Usually yes. Shares the buyer or insiders own can generally be voted for the deal. They can be left out of a separate vote, such as a majority-of-the-minority vote, where the law or the deal calls for one.

What is a quorum?

The least number of shares that must be present, in person or by proxy, for the meeting to act. It is often a majority of the shares entitled to vote.

Sources

Tracking AlphaBy Jera Value · Reviewed

Was this page useful?

Join the waitlist and stop checking EDGAR.

How many special situations do you hold right now? Optional