Skip to content

What is specific performance?

What specific performance is, full or limited, how courts have used it in three cases, and the Twitter case.

What it is

Specific performance is the target's right to have a court order the buyer to complete the deal, not only pay a fee or damages.

Also called: Target can force the close, Target can force the buyer to close

noyesnoyesyesnoThe buyer refuses to closeCan a court order the closing itself?A fee or damagesIs it the limited kind?A court may order itthe closingDebt ready, other tests met?A court may order itthe closingOther remediesoften the reverse fee

Whether a court grants the order is still the court's decision.

In plain words

Say you sign a contract to buy a one-of-a-kind painting. Then the seller refuses to hand it over.

Getting your money back isn't what you wanted. So you ask a judge to order the seller to hand it over.

Specific performance is that order: do what you agreed to do. In a merger, it usually means an order to the buyer to close.

An order to close

Specific performance is a court order to do what the agreement requires. In a merger, that usually means to close.

Say Woodgrove agreed to buy Litware for $50.00 a share. The closing conditions are met, but Woodgrove refuses to close.

Litware can ask a court to order Woodgrove to close. It's a remedy for when money alone wouldn't make up for the loss.

Most merger agreements say each side may ask a court for it. Whether a court grants it is still the court's decision.

Full or limited

Private equity deals often limit it. The two forms are:

Full
The target can ask a court to make the buyer close once the conditions are met.
Limited
The target can force the closing only if the buyer's debt financing is funded, or will fund at closing. If not, the agreement may limit the target to the reverse termination fee. It's also called specific performance lite.

One count looked at going-private deals. In these, a buyer takes a public company private. The buyer is often a private equity firm.

In its 2024 count, 34 of 36 deals let the target seek specific performance. Of those, 85% were the limited kind. In its 2023 count, 45% were limited and 55% full.Source 2

An agreement may let the target pursue specific performance or the fee, but not collect both.

How courts have used it

Three Delaware cases went different ways:

IBP v. Tyson Foods (2001)
The Delaware Court of Chancery ordered the merger agreement specifically performed. Tyson then agreed to close, and the merger closed on September 28, 2001.Source 4
Hexion v. Huntsman (2008)
The court ordered the buyer to perform its other obligations, but not to close. The agreement didn't allow that remedy. Huntsman ended the agreement in December 2008.Source 6
Tiffany v. LVMH (2020)
Tiffany sued on September 9, 2020, for an order making LVMH close. The two settled at a lower price before the trial, set for January 5, 2021.Source 1

Twitter and Elon Musk

Twitter's 2022 agreement with Elon Musk was the limited kind. It let Twitter force the closing only if the debt financing was funded, or would be at closing.Source 7

Twitter sued Musk for specific performance on July 12, 2022. A trial was set for October 17.Source 8Source 9

Musk agreed to close before the trial began, and the court paused the case. Then the deal closed on October 27, 2022, at the agreed $54.20 a share.Source 10

No court ordered Musk to close.

What it means for shareholders

Litware holders get their $50.00 a share only if the deal closes.

Specific performance can make an unwilling buyer close the deal at the agreed price.

Without it, the target may be left with a fee or a claim for damages.

On Tracking Alpha

Tracking Alpha's deal list and deal pages aren't open to the public yet. Once they open, they'll work as described here.

The checklist line Target can force the buyer to close reads Yes, Only in some cases or No.

Only in some cases typically means the limited kind. That is, only once the buyer's debt financing is funded or ready to fund.

On the list, it's the second protection dot and a tag.

As it looks on the site, with made-up values
  • Target can force the close
  • Target can force the close in some cases
  • Target can't force the close
  • Specific performance not in the filings

Easily confused with

Reverse termination fee
A payment, not an order to close. In many private equity deals, the fee is all the target can get when the financing doesn't fund.
Duty to litigate
The buyer's promise to fight a regulator's suit against the deal. Specific performance is the target's remedy against the buyer.

Questions

Can shareholders ask a court for specific performance?

Usually not. The right belongs to the companies that signed the merger agreement. Holders generally aren't parties to it.

How long does such a case take?

It varies. Courts can move quickly when a deal's deadline is near. Twitter sued on July 12, 2022, and its trial was set for October 17 of that year.Source 8

Which court decides?

Usually the one the agreement names. Many US merger agreements choose Delaware law and send disputes to the Delaware Court of Chancery.

Sources

  1. 1Company filing: Tiffany & Co., Form 8-K on the amended and restated merger agreement and the settlement with LVMH (October 29, 2020) (opens in a new tab)
  2. 2Study or report: Houlihan Lokey, 2024 Going Private Transaction Study (May 2025) (opens in a new tab)
  3. 3Court decision: In re IBP, Inc. Shareholders Litigation, Delaware Court of Chancery (2002), opinion (opens in a new tab)
  4. 4Company filing: Tyson Foods, Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 29, 2001 (opens in a new tab)
  5. 5Study or report: Hexion Specialty Chemicals v. Huntsman, Delaware Court of Chancery (2008), opinion (opens in a new tab)
  6. 6Company filing: Huntsman Corporation, Form 8-K on the settlement with Hexion and Apollo (December 2008) (opens in a new tab)
  7. 7Company filing: Twitter, Agreement and Plan of Merger with X Holdings, Form 8-K exhibit 2.1 (April 2022) (opens in a new tab)
  8. 8Study or report: Twitter vs. Musk: the complaint, Harvard Law School Forum (July 2022) (opens in a new tab)
  9. 9Study or report: Associated Press, Musk lawyers say Twitter refusing new $44B bid for company (October 6, 2022) (opens in a new tab)
  10. 10Company filing: Twitter, Form 8-K on the completion of the merger (October 27, 2022) (opens in a new tab)

Tracking AlphaBy Jera Value · Reviewed

Was this page useful?

Join the waitlist and stop checking EDGAR.

How many special situations do you hold right now? Optional